Theses and Case Law/ Litigation / by Cinthya Gonzalez Vera,Guadalupe Villa Figueroa,Raúl Alonso Flores Hernández, and Frida Isabel Velázquez Vargas.
On #ThesisFriday | On November 20, 2026, the Semanario Judicial published 35 legal principles: 11 court rulings and 24 isolated legal opinions.
We have selected the most relevant ones for you, which were issued by the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation and the Collegiate Circuit Courts:
Abstracts
Digital registration number: 2032947 / Thesis: P./J. 230/2026 (12th)
Case Law of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation
The right of indigenous peoples to self-determination is also recognized internationally.
The right of indigenous peoples and communities to self-governance is recognized both in the Constitution and in international treaties. Consequently, the lack of specific regulations implementing indigenous self-government within the domestic legal system is not a technical omission, but rather a substantive violation of applicable constitutional and treaty standards that prevents the full exercise of the collective rights of indigenous peoples and perpetuates patterns of historical exclusion incompatible with the substantive equality required by international human rights law.
Digital registration number: 2032953 / Thesis: P./J. 233/2026 (12th)
Case Law of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation
Article 333 of the Federal Law on the Protection of Industrial Property violates the right to a hearing by making the admission of testimonial evidence contingent upon its being contained in a documentary record.
The administrative procedure for declaring the expiration of a trademark registration must be designed in a way that facilitates the collection of the greatest possible volume of evidence; therefore, the admissibility of evidence cannot be contingent upon its inclusion in a document, as this violates the right to a hearing and undermines the effectiveness of the defense that individuals can present in administrative proceedings that may result in an act depriving them of their trademark rights. Furthermore, the written form of the testimony undermines its very nature.
Digital registration number: 2032971 / Thesis: P./J. 234/2026 (12th)
Case Law of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation
When ruling on a complaint, the Collegiate Court may assume jurisdiction to decide on the suspension of the amparo if the responsible authority failed to do so.
When an authority fails to rule on whether to grant a stay in a direct amparo proceeding, the Collegiate Court may and must make that decision when ruling on the complaint, provided it has the necessary documents. This is because a stay requires a prompt response and does not necessitate an additional proceeding. Therefore, remanding the matter to the authority would only delay the requested protection. Only when the Court lacks sufficient evidence should it remand the matter so that the authority may rule immediately.
Digital registration number: 2032949 / Thesis: I.5o.C.6 C (12a.)
Individual Opinion of the Circuit Courts
No court costs are payable when a lawsuit is filed against companies belonging to the same corporate group that share legal representation, and the action is successful only with respect to one of them.
The fact that a company is dismissed for lack of standing to be sued does not mean that the plaintiff must pay costs when the plaintiff also sued other companies in the same corporate group and obtained a favorable judgment against some of them. This is because the lawsuit was not without merit, since the plaintiff succeeded in having its claim recognized, at least in part, and that fact alone does not constitute grounds for ordering the plaintiff to pay costs.
Digital registration number: 2032950 / Thesis: I.5o.C.7 C (12a.)
Individual Opinion of the Circuit Courts
The death of the grantor, who held a lifetime usufruct, does not render the lessee’s occupancy of the property unlawful if the lessee is unaware of the death and has not been required to vacate the property.
When a person lends a property and dies, the person occupying it may remain there without that occupation being illegal solely because of that fact. To require that person to vacate the property, the owner must be aware of the death and must request that the occupant surrender the property. If no deadline was set, 30 days must elapse after that request.
Digital registration number: 2032954 / Thesis: VI.3o.A.78 A (12a.)
Individual Opinion of the Circuit Courts
Whether the parties acted in good or bad faith determines who has rights to what has been built, planted, or sown on another person's land.
When a person builds, sows, or plants on another person’s land, the legal consequences depend on whether the parties involved acted in good faith or bad faith. If the person carrying out the work acts in good faith, the landowner may retain the structure by paying the corresponding compensation, or may demand payment for the occupied land or rent, as the case may be. Conversely, if the person acting in bad faith and the landowner in good faith, the person loses what was built, sown, or planted without the right to compensation, and the landowner may demand its demolition or removal at the expense of the person who carried out the work. If the person carrying out the work acts in good faith, but the owner is aware of the work and permits it without objecting, the owner may only demand payment for the land or rent. When both parties act in bad faith, their conduct offsets each other, and the rules governing good faith on the part of both parties apply.
Digital registration number: 2032959 / Thesis: I.5o.C.8 C (12a.)
Individual Opinion of the Circuit Courts
When a maintenance creditor acts to defend her right to receive maintenance, it is improper to order her to pay expenses and costs, even if there are two judgments that are consistent in their operative provisions
This is because child support is a matter of public policy and social interest and protects vulnerable individuals; therefore, ordering the person obligated to pay child support to pay expenses and court costs would jeopardize their livelihood by forcing them to use their pension (which is presumed to be depleted each time it is paid), in addition to acting as a deterrent to asserting this right.
Digital registration number: 2032960 / Thesis: VII.1o.C.7 K (12a.)
Individual Opinion of the Circuit Courts
In an indirect amparo proceeding, the initial procedural order does not constitute grounds for dismissal when the claim concerns the refusal to pierce the corporate veil of a company in order to enforce a final judgment.
A refusal to pierce the corporate veil may affect the substantive rights of the enforcing party by preventing it from obtaining the awarded amount and causing irreparable harm. Therefore, the inadmissibility of the indirect amparo cannot be determined based on the initial order alone, as it is necessary to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the trial record to establish whether such a refusal is independent of the most recent decision rendered in the enforcement proceedings or whether it exhibits extraordinary characteristics that justify its challenge—an issue that must be resolved in the judgment.
Digital registration number: 2032976 / Thesis: VII.1o.C.1 K (12a.)
Individual Opinion of the Circuit Courts
In determining the amount of the security deposit required for the granting of a provisional stay in an indirect amparo proceeding, consideration must be given to the brief period during which the preliminary injunction will remain in effect.
Under the Amparo Law, a provisional suspension is generally of short duration; consequently, the District Court is practically unable to calculate at that time the damages that might be caused to the interested third party throughout the entire proceedings. Therefore, the amount of the security must be set solely for the period between its granting and the decision on the definitive suspension.
This publication was prepared byCinthya Gonzalez Vera,Guadalupe Villa Figueroa,Raúl Alonso Flores Hernández, and Frida Isabel Velázquez Vargas.


